Expressing a judgment in Method 1 is a really complicated train. Sadly Ferrari misplaced once more in 2024, McLaren gained, and so did Max Verstappen. Over the previous weeks, we evaluated the varied drivers regarding their performances all through the lately concluded season. Equally, a number of components should be thought-about when evaluating groups. Nonetheless, basing the evaluation on “measurable” standards makes the judgment much less tied to the subjective perceptions of the author, regardless of how goal these could also be. We thus thought-about 5 rationales for assessing the season of the ten groups, conscious that there may be different equally necessary components not examined as a result of they lack clear proof. As we are going to see within the abstract, the ultimate analysis, by assigning scores for every criterion, aligns intently with the ultimate standings of the constructors’ championship.
F1, fundamental technical challenge: Ferrari has an excellent basis
Within the first part, we assessed the baseline specs of the automobiles at first of the previous marketing campaign. There isn’t any doubt that Pink Bull arrived on the beginning line with a automobile that was simply as dominant because it had been on the finish of the 2023 season. Absolutely the worth of the RB20 within the early levels of the season was demonstrated by Sergio Perez, who completed second in three of the primary 4 rounds. The strongest various to the Austrian workforce was Scuderia Ferrari, because of Carlos Sainz’s victory in Australia and constant efficiency.
The McLaren MCL38, earlier than the Chinese language Grand Prix, didn’t appear able to troubling Pink Bull, despite the fact that its baseline seemed to be wonderful. Mercedes appeared a step behind its opponents, main the midfield however removed from difficult its direct rivals. From the Bahrain checks, it was clear that the Aston Martin AMR24 was a shadow of its wonderful predecessor, and for Fernando Alonso, the podiums of 2023 can be exhausting to duplicate. It was whole darkness for Alpine and Sauber, in addition to for Williams.
F1 2024: Improvement effectiveness: Ferrari stumbles in Spain
Though not a strictly “measurable” criterion, the title of “most improved workforce” undoubtedly goes to McLaren. From Imola onward, the papaya-colored automobile was, on common, probably the most aggressive within the discipline. This success was on account of a growth plan that unlocked the big potential of the Woking automobile. The precise reverse occurred at Pink Bull. The RB20 instantly appeared like a automobile with no growth margin, having reached the physiological restrict of the aerodynamic paradigm refined since 2022. The automobile’s growth did not preserve tempo with the competitors.
The height in Qatar is the hope Milton Keynes engineers cling to for 2025. For Ferrari, the event of the SF-24 stays the good remorse but additionally a superb demonstration of the power of the workforce led by Frederic Vasseur. The technical challenge 676 began with out important flaws; nevertheless, the automobile’s improve path was abruptly halted by the failed replace launched on the Spanish Grand Prix. The Iberian spherical was the primary in one of many season’s “triple headers.”
This concern finally prevented the engineers of the historic Italian workforce from rapidly understanding the correlation downside between the digital setting and on-track efficiency. The Italian workforce deserves credit score for not panicking, beginning once more from some extent of consistency, and redeveloping the Ferrari SF-24. The outcome was admirable. After a few years, the Modena-based workforce continued creating the automobile and step by step improved the efficiency of the 676 technical challenge till the top of its lifecycle.
As for Mercedes, regardless of the 4 victories obtained throughout the season—because of favorable circumstances, as was the case in Austria, and chilly weather conditions during which the Silver Arrows have been undoubtedly the perfect automobiles on the observe—the sensation is that Toto Wolff’s workforce nonetheless has not found out the best way to make a “wing automobile” work throughout a broader vary of circumstances. Noteworthy is the work executed by Alpine, a workforce that was virtually behind the grid at first of the season. Because of updates designed for the A525 challenge, Gasly and Ocon managed to regain positions within the midfield, topped by a double podium within the rain-soaked Brazilian Grand Prix.
F1 2024, reliability: Ferrari nonetheless falters
Relating to the criterion associated to reliability, it thought-about the variety of homologated energy unit parts throughout the season, grid penalties on account of exceeding the regulatory limits on parts, and race retirements brought on by technical points. When it comes to reliability, McLaren was the undisputed chief. Regardless of an prolonged calendar, the Woking automobiles by no means retired, with Norris nonetheless labeled within the Austrian Grand Prix regardless of the damaging collision with Max Verstappen.
McLaren and Aston Martin have been the one groups not requiring any homologation of energy unit parts exceeding the prescribed limits. A lot credit score goes to Mercedes for producing probably the most dependable engine within the discipline. The Pink Bull Powertrains unit confirmed some points with the inner combustion engine, forcing the world champion to homologate six inner combustion models. For Ferrari, the Achilles’ heel was undoubtedly the vitality retailer, affecting each the manufacturing facility workforce and its buyer groups.
Lastly, Alpine struggled once more this 12 months with technical points on the Renault energy unit, regardless of regulatory continuity. The 2025 season will mark the swan tune for the French engine, which will likely be changed by the Mercedes energy unit. A clarification is required relating to Williams’ knowledge: the variety of energy unit parts exceeding the regulatory cap and the grid penalties have been primarily on account of extreme crashes brought on by Sargeant, Albon, and Colapinto, which compelled the workforce to homologate new parts and rebuild solely destroyed automobiles.
This criterion additionally assessed not simply the drivers’ on-track administration but additionally the power to deal with contractual complexities throughout a season marked by a full of life driver market. Regardless of successful the constructors’ title unexpectedly earlier than the season started, McLaren‘s driver administration fell quick for a workforce with the potential to assist Norris’s championship dream. Lando’s errors, typically stemming from the psychological battle with Verstappen, and the liberty granted to the drivers till the Monza Grand Prix have been questionable.
Making certain equal remedy for so long as potential is comprehensible. Nonetheless, in some situations, the strategy by Stella’s workforce seemed to be a sporting suicide. Conversely, Vasseur skillfully managed inner rivalry between the 2 drivers, certainly one of whom was sidelined simply earlier than the season began. There was nice maturity from everybody, together with Leclerc, who navigated his relationship together with his teammate, mending rifts that arose throughout sure races (Las Vegas specifically). At Pink Bull, driver administration was poor on account of retaining a driver who was not performing.
Perez was overshadowed by Max, and his performances can’t be justified by the automobile’s technical decline. For the primary time in its historical past, Pink Bull appeared beholden to a driver, with a contract that protected him till the season’s finish. Jakobi, Checo’s long-time supervisor, held the workforce in examine, seemingly stopping a simple dismissal of the driving force as rumored earlier than the summer time break. The identical applies to Ricciardo, who was in all probability given extra time than warranted, taking helpful kilometers away from Liam Lawson. Mercedes additionally excelled in driver administration, regardless of Sir Lewis Hamilton’s sudden “betrayal.”
Although doubts surrounded some lackluster performances, Hamilton remained principally composed in 2024. The scenario at Williams was far more complicated. After parting methods with Sargeant belatedly, the workforce introduced in Colapinto, who confirmed pace and pure aggression. Nonetheless, his occasional reckless errors worsened the workforce’s monetary scenario. He was quick, challenged Albon, and appealed to a broad market. Nonetheless, he’ll sit out 2025 as his seat has already been handed to Carlos Sainz.
When it comes to pit stops, Ferrari is on the rostrum in tire adjustments. This rating was the simplest to assign, referencing the season’s DHL abstract rankings. As soon as once more, the highest groups dominated this particular rating, significantly Pink Bull. One of many positives for Milton Keynes this season was their on-track work, not solely in pit stops, which highlighted the mechanics’ talent, but additionally as a strategic weapon that the workforce used to compensate for the automobile’s evident shortcomings in varied circumstances.
McLaren and Ferrari accomplished the rostrum, highlighting the general progress of each groups, together with in on-track operations.
— see video above —
Purchase official Ferrari F1 merchandise!
Let different Scuderia Followers learn about us
